PHOTO: Real estate sales can be a stressful and financially draining ‘profession’. Image by rawpixel.com
The Inequities of the New Zealand Real Estate Industry: Commission-Based Compensation and Power Disparities
The real estate industry in New Zealand, like many other countries, plays a pivotal role in the national economy. However, behind the glossy facades of property listings and booming market values lies a stark reality of inequity within the industry. One of the primary factors contributing to this imbalance is the prevalent use of commission-based compensation for real estate agents. In New Zealand, this system puts the traditional real estate model at the center of power, leaving the income generators—real estate agents—with a disproportionately small share of the pie.
propertynoise.co.nz to launch real estate industry recruitment site
Commission-Only Compensation:
Unlike salaried employees, real estate agents in New Zealand often work on a commission-only basis. This means that their income is directly tied to the transactions they facilitate. While the potential for high earnings exists, the structure of commission-based pay creates a highly volatile financial environment for real estate agents. Agents face periods of uncertainty, with income fluctuating based on market conditions and their ability to close deals.
Lack of Salary and Benefits:
The absence of a fixed salary for real estate agents in New Zealand denies them the financial security enjoyed by traditional employees. Salaried positions typically provide a consistent income, benefits, and sometimes even bonuses, irrespective of the success or failure of individual transactions. In contrast, commission-only agents bear the brunt of market volatility and economic downturns without the safety net of a regular salary.
How effective is newspaper advertising in the real estate industry now?
Power Dynamics and Leverage:
The traditional real estate model in New Zealand further exacerbates these issues by concentrating power in the hands of those who own the agencies. Real estate agencies retain control over the transactions, marketing efforts, and overall business strategy. This centralized power dynamic often leaves real estate agents with limited influence and bargaining power, creating an imbalanced relationship.
Franchise Fees and Deductions:
Even when real estate agents secure a commission, their earnings are subject to deductions that further reduce their take-home pay. Many real estate agents operate under franchise models, where a significant portion of their commission is earmarked for franchise fees. These fees, often substantial, are deducted before agents receive their share of the commission. Consequently, agents find themselves with only a fraction of the total commission earned.
The inequities within the New Zealand real estate industry are deeply rooted in the commission-based compensation model and the power dynamics inherent in the traditional agency structure. Real estate agents, despite being the primary income generators for agencies, face financial instability, lack of employment benefits, and a limited ability to influence the industry’s direction.
Addressing these issues requires a reevaluation of the commission-based compensation system and a shift towards a more equitable distribution of power within the industry. Implementing alternative compensation structures and promoting fair business practices can contribute to a more balanced and sustainable real estate industry in New Zealand, benefiting both real estate agents and the broader community.
Supermodel, author and high-end real estate agent | WATCH
